Monthly Archives: October 2008

Duct tape shortage?

Rolf Penner- I’m getting all sorts of reports this morning about Bill Toews signs that have yet to receive the duct tape treatment. It’s now been three days since he was told to fix this and the jobs still not done.  Is there a shortage of duct tape or is he deliberately dragging his heels on this?

And not a peep out of the CWB on this.  If we don’t hear from them we’re going to have to assume that they’re officially endorsing Bill Toews.  Why not send them an email or give them a call asking them just that. ”Why are you endorsing Bill Toews?”

 1-800-275-4292   email  questions@cwb.ca      or try the

Media relations contact (204) 983- 3101, by fax at (204) 983-4678  email maureen_fitzhenry@cwb.ca

Duct Tape forever- Breaking the rules again!

Rolf Penner- Good grief Charlie Brown! Here we go again. Now Toews campaign literature has the CWB logo on it.

How’s he going to fix this one? Go door to door across the province and ask 5000 farmers if he can duct tape over their brochures?

This really does show poor judgement and it puts the Wheat Board in a very awkward, difficult and embarrassing position. It now needs to publicly state that even though its logo keeps appearing on Bill’s stuff they are not officially endorsing him over other candidates. And with ballots going in the mail this week they’re going to have to do it fast.  

Economist gives Rolf the Thumbs up!

The time to change the CWB from a compulsory, bureaucratic, cost ineffective agency of the federal government to a voluntary marketing organization is long past. There is no hard evidence that the CWB generates their claimed premium pries for prairie farmers, and lots of evidence that the organization in its present form costs prairie farmers and the prairie region lost revenue and income. Putting in place a market and marketing oriented board of directors is an important step toward accomplishing needed change in wheat and barley marketing on the prairies.
 
Rolf Penner is the candidate most likely to be able to contribute to these objectives. He knows the issues, he has a record of analysing the economics, marketing and political issues around prairie grain markets. I am pleased to endorse his candidacy for Director of the CWB.
 
Al Loyns
Former Prof of Ag Econ
University of Manitoba   

Pool returns vs CWB average prices CWRS- Where’s the premium?

Rolf Penner- Using 100% CWB data the following chart shows us the difference between final pool returns and the simple average of the CWB’s own posted asking prices for the crop year, calculated over the entire tonnage sold for that particular year.  

This is how much more money Western Canadian farmers would have gotten for their hard red spring wheat if the Wheat Board would have just gotten average prices. Not above average, just plain old average. Last year it was $1.3 billion, and what’s most disturbing is the trend, every year it seems to be getting worse.    

 

Sources: Pool returns and asking prices (page 15 of weekly grain statistics)

Funny how the asking prices aren’t on the CWB’s own website and are buried deep in the Canadian Grain Commissions website.

It really shouldn’t matter if you support the monopoly or not this kind of performance should be unacceptable to everyone.

Incumbent Breaking The Rules

Rolf Penner- All candidates in the Wheat Board Directors elections got the following email this past Saturday morning from Ian Craven the elections coordinator at Meyers Norris Penny.

“Good morning. Just a reminder that the CWB has not authorized the use of the CWB logo or corporate identity in this campaign by candidates. You should not be using the CWB logo or any of their corporate identity in any of your advertising.”

 Which is in response to campaign signs by the incumbent Director in district 10 that clearly have the Wheat Board logo on it.  Making it appear like the CWB is actually giving its stamp of approval to this candidate.

As of this morning the signs are still up in violation of the directive from the election coordinator.  It looks like the incumbent believes that these rules apply to people other than himself. It also raises serious questions as to the Boards neutrality in these elections.  An incumbent Director should know better, either he doesn’t, or he does, but doesn’t care.

Mr. Toews, the rules are there for everyone, you need to take down those signs. 

Update: I haven’t even been elected yet and already I’m getting results!

This afternoon I’m noticing duct tape on some (but not all) of Bill’s signs, covering up part of the CWB logo. He’s leaving the printing intact but covering up the little sheaf of wheat.  Stay tuned as the great Canadian Wheat Board directors election cover-up continues…   (this is as exciting as it gets folks!) Coffee Drinker 
Update 2 : Looks like I spoke too soon, Bill is really dragging his feet on righting this wrong.
 
 
 

 

 

8 Year average Malt Price comparison shows CWB $36/tonne worse than open market

Rolf Penner- John De Pape of Integrated Malt Barley Management has a very interesting price comparison chart here that he has been showing at some of the recent talks he has been giving. Continue reading

Market Power?

“One of the key claims made in support of a single-desk selling structure is based on the ability to exert market power within a given marketplace.

Of the 91 countries to which Canada exported non-durum wheat, only Ecuador potentially exhibited characteristics suggesting that Canada has sufficient market power to leverage prices.

Among the 41 countries to which Canada exported durum, market influence by Canada could potentially be exercised in six.

The analysis indicates that Canada does not hold sufficient market power in any of the 20 markets to which it has exported barley during the period under examination. “

-source: Informa

A farmers message for MP’s

Rolf Penner- Last march I sent this video to every MP in Ottawa to try and persuade them to let us sell our own malt barley.

Princess Parsley!

 Rolf Penner- Two can play at this game my-lady!

Parsleys notebook

2008 CWB producer survey

According to the June 2008 CWB survey   

57 % of Western farmers favour either a dual market or an open market over the single desk for wheat.

In Manitoba it was 58%   Continue reading

I’ve been tagged!!

 

 

 

     Parsley’s notebook

Vote Splitting

Rolf Penner-Like all things with the CWB, director elections are not like normal elections, they are more like a leadership race within a political party. To win you need 50% plus one of the votes, it’s called a preferential ballot system. You rank or number the choices in order of your personal preference.

The theory is that running multiple candidates will not so much split the vote but hopefully get more people voting on your side of the issue. People are more likely to vote for people they know from their own geographic area. Continue reading

How do you get a Ballot?

Producers who delivered wheat or barley to the CWB during the 2007-08 or 2008-09 crop years will be automatically included on the voters’ list. Those producers who need to establish their eligibility to vote are required to complete an “Application to Vote in the 2008 CWB Director Election” form and submit it to the Election Coordinator prior to November 14, 2008. Along with the application, producers can provide a statutory declaration, as per previous CWB elections. Continue reading

Spot Price Check- Friday October 24

 Sherlock Hard Red Spring Wheat      

  Bottineau, North Dakota         $7.45  per bushel CAD

  CWB Fixed Price/Manitoba     $5.92 per bushel CAD

      Difference                      - $1.53  per bushel CAD

 

Winter Wheat   

      Bottineau, North Dakota       $6.81  per bushel CAD

      CWB Fixed Price/Manitoba    $5.16  per bushel CAD

             Difference                   -$1.65   per bushel CAD

Continue reading

What happened with Oats

 

Since oats were taken out of the CWB in 1989, Canada has gone from having almost no oat exports to being the largest oat exporter in the world. Oats processing has grown 300 per cent and marketing costs have dropped by about one-third.