Category Archives: General

CWB Monopoly has some interesting supporters…

Canada Needs a New Plan for Afghanistan
Arm the Wheat Board
by Neil Kitson

We live in difficult times. Afghanistan is sucking up NATO money (and lives) at an alarming rate, with no end in sight and no measurable progress. Member countries are apparently unable to agree on policy or implementation. The laughable Afghanistan Compact, which has no basis in law, set mid-2007 as the goal for an end to all illegal armed activity. Maybe that seemed reasonable from the bar of a London hotel. (more) 

Rolf Penner- I don’t think this was written with the author’s tongue pressed firmly in his cheek. I think he’s serious. Read the whole thing.

CWB CONFIRMS MAJORITY OF FARMERS DEMAND BARLEY FREEDOM

OTTAWA, June 5, 2008 – Canadian Wheat Board Chair Larry Hill confirmed that an overwhelming majority of Western Canadian farmers are demanding barley marketing freedom during his appearance before the Senate Agriculture Committee today. David Herle, a long-time Liberal insider and Ralph Goodale advisor, conducted the poll for the CWB. Continue reading

David vs Goliath

CWB’s advertising & promotional spending

$1.307 million in 03-04
$1.928 million in 04-05
$1.639 million in 05-06
$1.417 million in 06-07

There are no limits as to how much of farmers money the Board can spend on advertising and self promotion. Continue reading

Wheat board monopoly created to control prices-history

ALTHOUGH we’re now hearing arguments that Prairie farmers should decide the issue by means of a vote, the Canadian Wheat Board’s monopoly was not originally imposed by popular demand. Nor was it created to enhance the financial well-being of Prairie farmers. It was implemented in the autumn of 1943 as a wartime price-control measure.

The board was started in 1935, the result of a series of very bad managerial decisions by the three Prairie wheat pools. In the 1920s, the Saskatchewan Wheat Pool, Manitoba Pool Elevators and the Alberta Wheat Pool jointly operated a voluntary board called the Central Selling Agency (CSA), and it operated successfully in a free market. (More)

Who actually sells your grain?

Rolf Penner- Most farmers believe that when they hand their wheat or barley over to the CWB, that it is actually the CWB that sells their grain for them. Well a lot of times that is just not the case. In any given year “Accredited Exporters” sell about half the wheat and up to 80% of the malting barley.  Here is a list of those accredited exporters. Continue reading

A could have been Canadian Success Story

From agriweek, July 21,2008 

SUCCESS STORY  
A local value-added venture makes the big time 
 
This isn’t supposed to be the best of times for grain processors, what with the soaring cost of raw grain, especially durum wheat. But just look at Dakota Growers Pasta Co. of Carrington. North Dakota, which began as a farmer-owned co-op to become the third-largest pasta producer in North America. It is having its best year ever with sales for the nine months ended April 30 up 37% to $195 million. For the latest quarter sales rose from $46 million to $78.5 million. Net income for the nine months was $5.02 million vs. $4.27 million last year (after a $960,000 one-time charge related to a pension issue) despite a dramatic increase in durum prices.  Continue reading

Putting the barley plebiscite numbers into perspective

Morris Dorosh put the barley vote in its proper prospective in his weekly publication agriweek.

“Over the last two years Alberta farmers grew 48.8% of the barley in western Canada, Saskatchewan farmers 42.3% and Manitoba 8.8%. The 50.6% of farmers in Manitoba who want the monopoly retained account for no more than 4.5% of the barley grown on the prairies, those in Saskatchewan for 19.1% and in Alberta for 7.4%. Those are small numbers.”

Fields of Gold

Dual Marketing down under

Rolf Penner- Here is how they are going to make it work in Australia. Unsurprisingly, they will still be offering ‘pooling’. The naysayers up here keep telling us a voluntary pool won’t work. They’re wrong of course and the Aussies are going give us another example of how it can work. This comes courtesy of Callum Downs Commodity News.

 July 8/08  AWB Wheat Marketing 2008/09 Season

 Yesterday I was briefed by Gordon Davis, Mitch Morison and Ian  Desborough on a number of issues, including their plans for wheat marketing for the first year of deregulation. Here are some points from those talks. Continue reading

Malt Barley Prices, CWB vs U.S. elevators

“The malt barley price in the US has outperformed CWB final payments for both two-row and six-row malting barley. In three out of the six most recent crop years analyzed, the average difference over those six years favours US elevator bids by $5.51 per tonne.”

Source: Informa

Frédéric Bastiat Quote:

“…we must wait until we have learned by experience — perhaps cruel experience — to trust in the state a little less and in mankind a little more.”

Letter to the editor- Kevin Archibald

Rolf Penner- This is unacceptable. And Unfortunately Harry is not the first reporter who has been banned from Board news conferences for asking tough but fair questions. I have recently been made aware of others.   

No censorship in democracy

‘Freedom’ is a word that is used a lot regarding Canadian Wheat Board discussions. Usually, it is in the context of marketing choice for farmers./ But it now appears there is an even more fundamental freedom at stake: freedom of the press. Continue reading

2000 Page Views!

Rolf Penner- As of tonight the stat counter on this website registered it’s 2000 th page view. Not to shabby considering it only went online October 15. A big thank-you to everyone who has come by to take a look so far.

Keep coming back I’ve got plenty of more good stuff to show you every single day.

                                                    Clapping Hands 

Thoughts on today’s debate

Rolf Penner- Well it really wasn’t so much of a debate as it was 5 guys answering a few questions. I tried to get a bit of a back and forth going with Bill Toews, but he didn’t like it and didn’t seem to want an actual exchange.  Which is too bad, I think farmers would have really liked to hear us actually debate our ideas in a more open manner.

 I was really impressed with Barry Reimer and Curtis Sims. I will not be one bit sorry if either of them get elected, I think they’re both solid guys with good heads on their shoulders who’ll do a good job of representing farmers interests around the board table. They are of the same belief as me, the board needs to be voluntary but it definitely should remain an option for farmers who want to use it. Continue reading

“Cash Plus”, another CWB marketing innovation

Rolf Penner- If you click on the following link you will see a flow chart explaining how the new CWB ‘cash plus’ program for malting barley really works. It reminds me a little of what Winston Churchill said when he looked at the troubles in Ireland, ” If you are not thoroughly confused by it all, then you really don’t understand the problem.” It also makes me wonder about the wheat boards favourite saying, the one about how it is run by farmers, I don’t know of any farmer who could come up with something as convoluted as this to try and sell their crop. A small army of government beaureaucrats that I can believe, farmers, no way.                 cash-plus-flow-chart.pdf